On Tap: The Latest Brewery and Distillery News In Rhode Island

Proclamation Brewing's controversial opening in Warwick, the start of holiday event season, and more from the state's craft brewing and distilling scene.

Welcome to On Tap, your monthly roundup of news and brews from Rhode Island’s craft beer and distilling scene. Sign up to receive On Tap in your inbox every month here. As always, follow along with our social media at @rimonthly and @RImonthly more food and drink news, and email any beer and spirits tips to lclem@rimonthly.com. Special thanks to Amelia Lowthian who helped compile this month’s Events and Happenings. Cheers!

FULL POUR

Proclamation Brewing reopened an iconic Warwick brewery. For some, it will never be the same.

A photo of a taproom with leather couches and a lit-up Proclamation sign on the wall.

Proclamation Brewing reopened the brewery at 298 Kilvert St., Warwick, to the public this week. (Photos by Lauren Clem)

Rhode Island’s newest brewery opened its doors this week, delivering revamped branding and a freshly renovated taproom at a location with a long history in Rhode Island’s craft beer scene. Proclamation Brewing, which acquired the assets of Proclamation Ale Company following the latter’s closure in May, is located in the same Warwick industrial park where Proc built up an early reputation as one of the most popular breweries on the local craft circuit.

The taproom opened its doors to the public on Wednesday, and a friends and family event the previous night drew a large crowd to the sleek industrial taproom. While the location is familiar, longtime Proc fans will notice several differences, including new furniture, lounge-style seating areas and a collection of flat-screen TVs positioned around the room. The business opened with six beers on tap, including three of the signature IPAs — Ordinary Man, Tendril and Derivative — for which the brewery was known.

The opening comes on the heels of a long and bitter dispute that has divided the craft beer community. Playing out on social media over the past few months, the debate has pitted devotees of the original Proc against those who see the opening as simply another owner taking up the mantle of an iconic brand. At the center of the dispute are the new owner, Richard Storti — an investor whose previous involvement includes The District in Providence and North Kingstown’s Lil’ Rhody Pickleball Club — and Joshua Karten, a consultant who was previously a part-owner of Proc and filed a lawsuit against the business after he was terminated as an employee in 2020.

The resulting firestorm is both a cautionary tale about what happens when friends mix business and personal relationships and a testament to the passion of the craft beer community. Some have sworn never to set foot in the new Proc. Others are thrilled to see their favorite beers return to the market. Almost everyone who drinks beer in Rhode Island has an opinion, and most have been vocal about it online.

Proclamation on the Rise

To fully tell the story of what happened to Proclamation, you need to go back to at least 2016, when the brewery was a bright light in Rhode Island’s burgeoning craft beer scene.

Across the state, a small number of breweries were working round the clock to meet the expanding demand for craft beer. That included advocating at the State House to increase the limit on how much beer a brewery could legally sell to a visitor, then set at seventy-two ounces. In Warwick, the fight had attracted attention. An anonymous writer sent a letter to Proclamation Ale Company — then a two-year-old brewery regularly attracting crowds to its beer releases — chastising local brewers for trying to break into the retail liquor market. Dave Witham, primary owner and the public face of the brewery, knew exactly how to respond.

“It’s Proclamation,” he told an AP reporter at the time. “I thought we should make a statement.”

In a photo posted to the former company’s Facebook page, Witham set fire to the letter while he and two of the business’s employees gave the middle finger to the camera. The photo went viral among craft beer lovers, many of them expressing support in the comments. The response was in character for Witham, whose devotion to the product and passion for the growing industry had earned Proclamation a loyal following in Rhode Island and beyond.

The letter (also posted to Facebook) was addressed to Karten, a minority owner later listed in legal documents as the brewery’s chief operating officer. Though not as public facing as Witham, Karten played a role in the day-to-day operation of the business, with a 2025 legal finding describing his responsibilities in accounting, streamlining financial operations and fundraising. Karten was also involved with advocating statewide, serving a stint as president of the Rhode Island Brewers Guild. Perhaps more important than their business relationship, Karten and Witham were friends. They first met in 2003, long before Proc existed, and played in a band together before going into business.

It’s not clear when the friendship began to sour, but the deterioration of their business relationship has been well documented in legal records. In May of 2020, Karten filed suit against Proclamation after he was terminated as an employee. The record — which is publicly available online — is rife with allegations of financial mismanagement by both parties, and the brewery filed a counterclaim against Karten. The suit, which Karten characterizes as a “shareholder dispute,” would drag on for the next five years. In a decision filed earlier this year, a judge ruled Karten was entitled to his ownership interest in Proc, valued at $329,249.58.

In the midst of the lawsuit, tragedy struck. In November of 2020, Witham was diagnosed with cancer. He died just over a month later on Christmas Day. The outpouring of grief was immense, with craft beer drinkers throughout southern New England remembering a figure who’d loomed large in the early craft scene. Witham’s wife, Lori, took over managing the brewery after Dave’s death, and for years Proc celebrated his memory with an annual “Daveapalooza” event featuring all his favorite things: skateboarding, music, food and beer.

The End of an Era

While the Proc pride was strong, behind the scenes, the industry was struggling. COVID had dealt a blow to small businesses, and changes in consumer patterns meant breweries no longer enjoyed the same guaranteed success as before. After Dave’s death, Lori assumed the role of defendant in the ongoing lawsuit. In May of 2026, she announced on social media that Proc would be closing. In her closing announcement, she cited the lawsuit as well as lingering post-COVID challenges and industry shifts as factors that contributed to the closure. (Storti and Karten contest that the lawsuit had a significant impact on the brewery’s finances.)

For those who’d become part of the Proc community, the closure meant the end of an era in craft beer. For others, it was an opportunity. Storti was a businessman and investor who previously offered to purchase the brewery in 2023, which Lori declined. Storti tells Rhode Island Monthly he became familiar with the brewery and its legal struggles from Karten while the lawsuit was ongoing. The two initially connected, Storti says, because they both shared the same lawyer.

After Proc closed in May, the bank took control of its assets due to outstanding debt. Storti purchased those assets, including the brewery equipment, recipes and intellectual property. He brought on Karten as a consultant to help manage the brewery, and the two began the process of relaunching the brand under the name Proclamation Brewing.

What happened next was indicative of the strong loyalty many felt to Witham and the original Proc. As rumors of Karten’s involvement began to swirl, many criticized the not-yet-reopened business online. In September, Storti posted in the Rhode Island Craft Beer Community Facebook group in an attempt to clear the air and introduce himself as the new owner. The company, he said, is “a new Proc purchased with every intention of continuing the brand and earning your trust.” He also announced his plan to label the brewery’s first three releases as a “Legacy Series, paying homage to Dave and Lori’s hard work, creative talent and passion. They built something people genuinely love, and we don’t take that lightly. I intend to reach out to Lori directly, and I hope she’ll agree to let us host a Proclamation Ale Day and use that occasion to support [Dave and Lori’s daughter] Harper.”

In response, Lori released her own statement. Storti, she said, had not discussed the idea of supporting Harper with her and did not have her endorsement.

“Despite being in direct communication with Richard many times, no such conversation about Harper has taken place with me,” she wrote. “Neither Harper nor I is involved with the new company, and I have not endorsed the use of our family’s story or Dave’s legacy in connection with its relaunch. Whatever the intention behind those gestures, I ask that this distinction be respected.”

Lori also discussed the difficulty of closing a brewery that had been the dream of her late husband and which she had been involved with for more than a decade.

“What many people now see as a reopening therefore feels very different to those of us who lived through the last six years. Regardless of how familiar the name, recipes or social media accounts may be, this is a new company. No one who was part of Proclamation Ale Company when we closed the doors is involved with it,” she wrote.

What Comes Next

Speaking with Rhode Island Monthly last week, Storti and Karten say their interest is in maintaining a brand that has built up a legacy in the craft beer market.

“I believe the company deserves and the brand deserves to be in the market. I believe it did a lot for the craft beer market. What Dave and I built years ago, I think it deserves to be here,” Karten says.

Asked why they decided to go forward with labeling their three flagship beers as a “Legacy Series,” Storti and Karten reiterated they believe the brand’s legacy deserves to continue.

“I understand people disagree, and that’s OK. I respect their positions, no matter who it is,” Karten says. “I stand by my position that that legacy, whatever people want to remember it as — they want to remember it as a person, they want to remember it as a company — it deserves to be in the marketplace, and it deserves to be remembered.”

Storti says their approach to the brand reflects changes in the craft beer industry since the brewery’s early days.

“The market changed. When people used to go to wait in line for a new release and the taproom would do twenty, thirty thousand dollars in eight hours — it doesn’t do that anymore,” he says. “Now you have to have something of value for the consumer to appreciate and want to be hanging in that space because they have a lot of other options.”

With that in mind, the pair completed an extensive renovation of the brewery’s taproom. Where arcade games once lined the walls, visitors will now find warm wood accents, sleek TV screens and a combination of high-top and lounge-style seating areas. The arcade games, Storti says, were sold to pay for the chandelier-style lighting fixtures.

The beer was updated as well, with Karten saying they modified the original recipes to make them “more approachable and more shelf stable and a higher quality.” This includes adjusting the alcohol content. Where Ordinary Man once came in at 6.5 percent alcohol by volume and Tendril at 7 percent, the beers are now listed at 5.5 percent and 6 percent, respectively.

“We’re hoping to appeal to a wide market,” Karten says.

At least some portion of the craft beer community seems receptive to the changes, with about 150 liquor stores now carrying the revamped beers. Storti says he’s not concerned about the criticism at the business’s outset, as he believes many people are excited and encouraged by the investment they’ve made in the product. Eventually, he says, he plans to serve food on the property and apply for a full Class B liquor license.

In the meantime, one thing’s for certain.

“We’re not going anywhere,” Storti says.

A glass featuring a P logo on a wooden bar.

The Ordinary Man IPA at Proclamation Brewing.

 

SMALL SIPS

• Moniker Brewery recently cleared its fire inspection and is getting ready to reopen the former Ravenous Brewing Company in Cumberland as Moniker North. Stay tuned on their social media for an opening date, and read our story from May for more info.

• Screaming Unicorn, the semi-permanent food pop-up at Buttonwoods Brewery in Providence, will vacate its space in the brewery next month. Owner Stephanie Rapoza announced the change on social media, noting the business is looking for a new space. Screaming Unicorn — known for its smash burgers, sandwiches, mac and cheese, and fries — is also accepting orders for Thanksgiving take-and-heat sides.

 

EVENTS AND HAPPENINGS

• Tickets are still available for the Friendsgiving barbecue at Trágmar Ale Works this Saturday, Nov. 14, from 3 to 6 p.m. Enjoy a Thanksgiving meal courtesy of Waypoint BBQ, then stick around for live music from A.K. Cody from 6 to 9 p.m. Food orders are $15 for a smoked turkey sandwich and $25 for the full turkey dinner.

• The next Beer Friends Meet-up will take place at the Narragansett taproom on Saturday, Nov. 14, at noon. Tag along to meet fellow craft beer enthusiasts and make some new friends.

• Love Live Beerworks is hosting Emo Yoga with Crystal Rose Yoga on Sunday, Nov. 15, at 2 p.m., where you can move to the sound of pop punk and emo music. The beginner-friendly class costs $29 plus fees and comes with a drink ticket to stick around and hang out after. Tickets are available online here.

• If you’re a “Survivor” fan, don’t miss the “Survivor” 51 watch party at Narragansett Beer on Wednesday, Nov. 18, from 6 to 10 p.m. Meet celebrity guest Bruce Perreault and test your skills (and knowledge) with “Survivor” challenges.

• O’Brien and Brough will host a Thanksgiving cocktail class on Saturday, Nov. 21, from 1 to 3 p.m. Learn to impress your guests this holiday season with handcrafted, balanced cocktails. Tickets are $50 and include a welcome cocktail and the opportunity to make (and enjoy) two cocktails, plus snacks and 10 percent off any bottles purchased.

• Newport Harbor Island Resort will host a bourbon, rum and fall-inspired cocktail competition with Litchfield Distillery and Bellevue Wine and Spirits on Sunday, Nov. 22, at 2 p.m. Tickets are $20 and available online here.

• Gilligan’s Pub in Providence is relaunching its Miracle on Chalkstone holiday pop-up from Nov. 20 through Dec. 31 this year. Stop in for festive cocktails, over-the-top decorations and a new mug design to bring the holidays to life. Check out our story from last year’s pop-up.

• Phantom Farms Brewing is hosting Pintsgiving from 4 to 11 p.m. on Thanksgiving Eve, featuring live music, food trucks, mocktails and more. Grab a pint of the Elegant Viking IPA, back on the menu just in time for the holidays.

• Head over to Sons of Liberty Spirts this Nov. 27 — a.k.a. Black Friday — to find a curated market from Juicy Market featuring jewelry, art, home goods, treats and more from Rhode Island vendors.

• Join Ragged Island Brewing Company on Saturday, Nov. 28, at 6:30 p.m. for a Barn Session featuring live music from Oblivious Fools and food from California Taco Shop. Tickets are $10 each and available online.

• Drag, pro-wrestling, burlesque and live music all in one night? Don’t miss CabaRestle at Buttonwoods Brewery on Saturday, Nov. 28, at 8 p.m., featuring the PWRUP band.

• The Guild is partnering with Field of Artisans for their seventh annual Hoppy Holidays event on Dec. 5 and 6 starting at noon, featuring more than seventy local vendors. More details available here.

• Apponaug Brewing Company will host a holiday-themed Sip & Script on Tuesday, Dec. 8, at 6:30 p.m. Learn about modern calligraphy and ornamental letting at this beginner-friendly workshop. Tickets are $70 per person and available online.

• Tickets are on sale for the third annual Rhode Island’s Finest Real Ale Festival, taking place at The Guild in Pawtucket on Friday and Saturday, Jan. 15 and 16. The festival will feature twenty-five to thirty offerings from breweries around New England, all served out of casks. Tickets are $30 plus fees and include a commemorative pint glass and your first two pints. Buy tickets online here.

• While you’re at it, grab tickets for the Rhode Island Brew Fest, taking place at the WaterFire Arts Center on Saturday, Jan. 30. Tickets are $60 each plus fees and include samples from fifty-plus breweries, with a portion of sales benefitting the Rhode Island Brewers Guild.

• Lawson’s Finest Liquids (of Vermont brewing fame) has announced the return of its Cosmic Shift IPA as a seasonal Good Brew for a Cause. The Housing Network of Rhode Island is one of the nonprofits that will benefit from the initiative, with a portion of sales from all Cosmic Shift IPAs sold in Rhode Island donated to the organization.

• Here’s a fun promotion from Grey Sail: The brewery has hidden wooden tokens in packs of Middle Child IPA sold around the state. Find a token, and you can redeem it for a free pint glass at the Westerly tasting room.

• This holiday season, Narragansett Beer is launching the Share A ’Gansett campaign featuring limited-edition cans and packaging celebrating vintage characters from the brand’s 136-year-old marketing history. Fans will have the chance to name one of the characters (a vintage ’Gansett pup) through a social media vote.

 

LABEL OF THE MONTH

A dark bottle featuring an illustration of a pumpkin with a pint can beside it.

(Courtesy of Taproot Brewing Company)

Imperial Pumpkin by Taproot Brewing Company

From @taprootbeer: “Wicked Squashed has a bigger, bolder brother. Both start with our classic pumpkin ale, but Imperial takes it a step further with two years in Willet bourbon barrels and nearly double the alcohol. The classic or the big brother — which one’s your pick?” taprootbeer.com

RELATED ARTICLES

Meet the Rhody Beer Enthusiasts Behind 3 Dudes’ Brews

Take a Craft Beer Tour of Ireland with this Rhode Island Brewery

How Two Local Brewery Owners are Running Their Businesses Through Cancer